What if God wants your plans to fall apart?

6 min. to read.

I had plans. They were good plans, intended to bring good things about. Plans for my church, like how we could grow and become of great influence in our community. Plans for my family, how things needed to look for a comfortable and peaceful home life. Plans for my writing, so that I could reach more people, and maybe even start making some income! They were good plans.


Then life, and circumstances and God didn’t cooperate with my plans. After depression and nearly burning out, I started growing emotionally and spiritually. I found myself questioning some of my motives and plans. Then my wife ran out of steam. She’d been carrying me emotionally for too long. She needed her own recovery. The plans I had for how my family ought to look disolved. Some wonderful, gifted, and impactful people moved on from our church. The plans I envisioned no longer seemed possible.

Even these last three months, my plans fell apart! Circumstances were out of my control. All my discretionary moments, the ones I had planned on using for writing, were called into service. No forward motion on my book. No forward motion on my online course. I couldn’t stay on top of my blogging schedule or my Facebook page. I felt like I fell off the rails.

This week I found an unexpected reminder that has entirely shifted my attitude. If you’re feeling like life and circumstances and God aren’t cooperating with you, maybe it will encourage you too.

Quote - Mess God Intends

Wait! That’s not in the plan!

As a part of my First Things First process, I read a short section of scripture and journal on it. Just having finished one book, I decided to start the Gospel of Matthew.

The 1st chapter begins with Jesus’ ancestry and the introduction to the well-known story of Jesus’ birth. As I read, I felt a connection to Joseph. And not in a good way!

Joseph had plans. He was engaged to an eligible woman. He was getting married, growing his family and influence in the community. Those were good steps. The right steps, at least in the eys of his community.

Then Mary told him the news.

She was pregnant. That’s not in the plan! A couple getting pregnant before marriage was not a step in the right direction. But it got worse. Joseph hadn’t even slept with Mary. The baby wasn’t his! Getting married to a woman who slept around? Getting married while she was pregnant with another man’s child? Raising this child? None of that was in the plan.

Now, Joseph seems like a nice man. He didn’t want to be a complete jerk. He decided that he wouldn’t marry Mary, but he wouldn’t make a big deal out of it. He didn’t want to take on someone else’s drama, but he also didn’t feel the need to, for example, have her stoned for adultery (which he could have done.) I imageine that he wanted out of the drama and consequences. He wanted to get back to his plans.

Is God allowed to do that?

Here’s where I had my insight. See, I’ve been feeling put out and frustrated that my plans have been derailed. I’ve been fighting it, feeling like I needed to get my plans back on track.

But then there’s Joseph’s story. All his plans got derailed, and it was exactly what God wanted. In fact, God was in the process of giving birth to something new and powerful in the middle of Joseph’s mess. His plans were in tatters; God’s plans were just starting to take shape!

Now, as A Good Christian Kid™ I’m long-trained to accept God’s plans when they show up. Trust God. God has good plans for us! Right? But what if God’s plans include a mess? What if they include something downright ungodly?

Joseph’s plans were the ones the good synagogue people approved of. Marry a good girl. Work hard. Grow your influence in the community. Be a Godly man, living above reproach. That’s how God leads us to live, right? That’s a Godly life, right?
Getting pregnant outside of marriage? That’s not godly! In Joseph’s culture marrying a woman pregnant with another man’s child was not OK. The law said she could justifiably be executed for adultery. He’d be marrying a criminal. He’s be raising a child that wasn’t his. That child would be a reminder, every day of his life, of the stain on his marriage, on his wife, on his reputation. That can’t be Godly, right?

Yet, it was exactly what God wanted.

Now, I understand this reflection is really focused on the male perspective. I know there are other ways to see this story. I know that this isn’t what you’d call good clean exegesis. But, as I was journaling, this one thought impacted me deeply.

I’ve been struggling all summer feeling that my plans were falling apart. Some of the things that have been happening are decidedly messy, not something I want to brag about, not something that fits my image of the good life. But what if this mess is exactly what God wants to do in my life?

  • What if a hit to my reputation (“Didn’t he nearly burn out? Didn’t his poor leadership nearly incapacitate his church?) is exactly what God needs to do a new work in me?
  • What if me getting embroiled in other people’s pain and drama is exactly where God wants to work?
  • Maybe me, in a cast and on crutches, creates the space for God to bring to life something new and powerful?

Perhaps you’re fighting with the collapse of your own plans. Maybe other people’s terrible choices have splashed onto you, and you’re walking around bearing the consequences of their mess. Maybe the soil has been hard, and the seeds you’ve planted didn’t take. Maybe the mess you’re in right now is exactly the space God needs to birth an amazing act of salvation and grace in your life and community.

May you open your arms to God, who is at work creating life in chaos, and grow in trust, that this God sees you, cares for you, and has good things planned for you—even when your own plans are falling apart.

10 thoughts on “What if God wants your plans to fall apart?

  1. Good article Marc! It is hard to see God’s hand in our life and our plans when it is not going the way we think it should. I like the idea that in the midst of the chaos I might be playing an important role that I can’t see but it does not mean I am abandoned! Press on!

    1. Hey Jim, thanks for your thoughts. It *is* hard isn’t it? Almost impossible. I guess this is just a different perspective. Maybe God’s got something going on in the middle of my mess. Maybe I don’t have to quite so stressed out about it.

  2. Wonderfully authentic article Marc!
    Thank you for being so transparent and genuine with us.
    This is how I personally think of it: Who wants a friend who hides? Who wants to listen or read one word from someone that sweeps human conflict under the rug…who would want to listen to….. a coward? I don’t and I certainly don’t think the world does either.
    While we are all in the middle of our own personal struggles (and anyone who says they aren’t …well…just wait…it’ll come) it can take the burden off the shoulders allowing God to work out the details.
    ?Knowing He has it ALL under control…and a better outcome than we could ever dream possible opens up the purest sense of peace that I personally have ever experienced.
    Jeremiah 29: 11
    ??Keep writing. The world needs to hear you through your words.??

  3. Great post as I have recently been struggling with, “WHEN GOD?” I am doing all the things..

    But, God is in the process of giving birth to something new and powerful in the middle of my mess.

    I shall remain encouraged.

  4. Thank you for this article, I needed to hear some of your revelations.
    I found out yesterday that I have been dismissed from medical school. I had not done well in two courses, I took a remediation exam for one of them and passed, but because I failed two I had to meet before a student performance committee. Now, mind you I was fully expecting them to say I have to repeat the year. It is very very rare to be kicked out completely, and everyone was reminding me of this. I knew I needed to work on anatomy, so I put together a plan that would make these next 7 months fruitful before the next term began… I received the letter yesterday about being dismissed, and am having a hard time. I’ve been working towards this since I was 14 years old, and it seemed like it was God’s will for me to become a physician so I could help people who were unable to help themselves, and to be God’s hands and feet.. I could try again, but how do I know if this is God’s plan or my plan?

    1. Oh man… that is brutal. I am so sorry for the pain and uncertainty that you are experiencing right now. I can’t speak to whether this is God’s plan or whether some good can come out of this or not. All I can do is encourage you to cling to Jesus. Focus on living in a sense of awareness of His presence in each moment. You are not alone — not even in an incredibly difficult and painful experience as this.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to abide by civil commenting standards. I understand my comment may be deleted if it violates the comment policy of this website.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.